Bonesaw vs. Ubersaw

I think there may be a thread about this already (or maybe it was on the Steam forums, which I hardly take seriously), but I'm curious to see people's opinion now that it's been a while since the medic update.

Which do you prefer and why?

Ubersaw, getting uber is good. Swing speed is nothing.

Ubersaw.

Ubersaw. in comparison to the Bonesaw, it's Op


(same goes for Bonesaw)

Quote:

???

Bonesaw is OP in comparison to not having any saw at all.

Oh. Clever

Ubersaw for sure. The only time the negative impact of the swing speed comes up is when you're swinging at (and hitting) someone more than once in a row. That rarely if ever happens in matches, so the pros faaaaaar outweigh the cons for me.

The slower attack speed of the übersaw is a marginal penalty as it is not the attack speed that makes the bonesaw a good melee weapon to begin with. High burst damage is what makes the melee weapons great, not their DPS. If the übersaw had a much lower burst damage, like the axtinguisher, you would actually have to choose between combat ability or utility. As of now the übersaw can do the same thing as the bonesaw (high burst melee attacks) while adding versatility on top of that.

there's no reason to use the bonesaw. Thus, i use the bonesaw.